Shareholders’ agreement: why the law alone is not enough to protect your shares

Forming a company with others means agreeing to share decision-making power, the distribution of value, and, often, the very future of the venture with third parties. French law certainly governs the ownership of corporate shares and the rights attached to them. But this legal protection, designed to apply to all companies without distinction, leaves gaps that only a shareholders’ agreement can fill.

Ownership of securities: a form of protection that future partners often wish to regulate

The articles of incorporation and general corporate law guarantee a partner a set of basic rights attached to their shares: the right to vote, the right to dividends, the right to information, and the right to transfer their shares. This set of rights is a matter of public policy in certain respects – for example, a partner cannot be completely deprived of their right to vote or to receive their share of profits.

However, this protection has three structural limitations.

It is general in nature and not tailored to the specific business venture. The law establishes a framework applicable to all companies of the same legal form, without regard for the balance intended by the founders: the distribution of power between majority and minority shareholders, each shareholder’s involvement in management, the anticipated exit strategy, and so on.

It does not address deadlock situations. What happens when two shareholders with equal stakes can no longer reach an agreement? By default, corporate law provides no mechanism to break a deadlock: no compulsory buyout procedure, no mediation clause, and no organized exit scenario.

It does not control the entry of unwanted third parties into the company’s capital. Unless otherwise specified in the articles of incorporation, the transfer of shares is, in principle, unrestricted among partners and, depending on the corporate form, may also be unrestricted with respect to third parties. A partner may thus find themselves joined by someone they neither chose nor approved – a competitor, an heir with whom no relationship of trust exists, or an investor whose objectives are incompatible with those of the original project.

The Shareholders’ Agreement: A Customized Contract Among Shareholders

A shareholders’ agreement is a non-statutory agreement signed by all or some of the shareholders. It supplements the articles of incorporation to organize, with the precision required by the project, the long-term relationships among shareholders. Unlike the articles of incorporation, it remains confidential – a significant advantage, since the articles of incorporation are filed with the court registry and are accessible to third parties.

A well-drafted agreement can address the following points, among others:

Control of Share Ownership: Approval, preemptive, or temporary non-transferability clauses allow for filtering or delaying the entry of new shareholders and guarantee the signatories a right of review – or even a right of first refusal – regarding any transfer of shares.

Organized exit from the company: “Tag-along” clauses, which allow a minority shareholder to sell their shares under the same terms as a selling majority shareholder, and “drag-along” clauses, which require a minority shareholder to participate in a sale decided by a majority shareholder, prevent a shareholder from being left alone as a minority shareholder alongside a buyer they did not choose.

Resolving Deadlocks: A mandatory buyout clause or a mediation procedure prior to any legal action helps prevent the company from becoming paralyzed – and the resulting lengthy and costly proceedings – when shareholders with equal stakes can no longer agree on the strategy to follow.

Governance: The agreement may specify the distribution of powers among management bodies, the majorities required for structural decisions (capital increases, changes to the corporate purpose, disposal of essential assets), or even enhanced disclosure requirements for minority partners.

Partners’ personal commitments: Non-competition, exclusivity, or non-solicitation clauses bind each signatory personally, with contractual penalties (often liquidated damages) in the event of a breach—a level of effectiveness that articles of incorporation, which are by nature less flexible, do not always provide.

Legal certainty that comes at a cost: the cost of negotiating it

A shareholders’ agreement is only as valuable as its drafting. A poorly calibrated forced buyout clause can backfire on its beneficiary; a disproportionate non-compete clause may be struck down by a judge; and an imprecise relationship between the agreement and the articles of incorporation can create, in the event of a conflict between the two documents, the very uncertainty that the agreement was specifically intended to prevent.

This is why drafting a shareholders’ agreement requires anticipating—from the very inception of the company or upon the arrival of a new partner – scenarios involving disagreement, exit, or transfer – rather than discovering them only when they occur.

Further reading : How to Create a Company in France as a Foreigner: Legal Rules, Residency Requirements, and Tax Guidance ; Setting up a company in France: capital deposit challenges for foreign founders.